When Singled Out debuted on MTV on June 5, 1995, dating shows weren’t exactly subtle. Forget the romantic roses and candlelit dinners. This show ran on free soda, loud outfits, and contestants willing to wear a toilet seat like a necklace because they’d been “dumped.” If you think reality TV is unhinged now, this was the warm-up act. At the center of it all stood Jenny McCarthy, then 22, corralling over-caffeinated singles with the energy of someone who knew this gig could change everything.
MTV didn’t want to hire a Playboy centerfold, even one freshly crowned Playmate of the Year. So McCarthy did what any determined future TV star would do. She stood in line with hundreds of hopefuls and waited. Her cover only blew when she made the final six. “I could almost hear the collective ‘Oh, brother… But to their credit, they didn’t stop me,” she told US Weekly.
What sold them wasn’t her résumé. It was her attitude. She leaned into self-deprecating jokes, refused to be intimidated by the guys, and went full goofball. Her confidence did the rest. The only odd rule was a no-stomach policy during season one. Crop tops were apparently too much for executives worried she might “rip all my clothes off or something.”
The format was simple and absurd. Masked pickers sat on thrones. Singles got eliminated based on categories like facial hair or height. Survivors danced through stunts that included pretending to be an excited car or convincing a human-sized roach to check into a roach motel. People did it because cameras were rolling and it was MTV.
McCarthy thrived in the madness. Most contestants didn’t flirt. They panicked. “Most of the guys were terrified of me,” she said. She smacked faces on camera, hard enough that MTV hired extra security. If someone pinched her off-camera, she waited for the red light and handled it herself.
By 1997, the show had turned McCarthy into a Rolling Stone cover star. She didn’t even realize how big that was. “I actually said, ‘Why would a rock magazine want me on their cover?’” That cover opened every door, including the exit. She left for her NBC sitcom Jenny, passing the baton to Carmen Electra, who called McCarthy “a girls’ girl” with the best energy.
Fast forward 31 years and McCarthy, now 53, still looks like herself. She recently told People that she survived a brutal 2025 marked by nine mouth surgeries, a year on antibiotics, and infections so severe they spread to her eyes. She joked about weight loss caused by stitches and soft food. She celebrated being able to eat again like it was a comeback tour.
She’s back judging season 14 of The Masked Singer, still cracking jokes, still loud when needed. At home in Illinois, she sleeps beside husband Donnie Wahlberg with noise-cancelling headphones and what he calls the “Great Wall of China” made of pillows. Love adapts.
Singled Out didn’t age politely. That’s the point. It was messy, loud, and unapologetic. McCarthy was too. And three decades later, that same edge still fits her just fine.
RELATED: Zendaya’s Transition From Child Star to Hollywood Celebrity Is Nearly Flawless—Zero Scandals
